2025 Mock Drafts | Superflex | SF | Dynasty | Mock Drafts | NFL Draft Prospects

SuperFlex Rookie Mock Draft | 4 Rounds | The Best NFL Prospects

See the top 48 SuperFlex prospects! Join @reflipewthenuz @smingdynasty @_bobbybishop @MJohrendt23 @pistol_pete026 @dropthemikeff for 4 rounds of 2025 NFL Draft Rookies in our latest Mock Draft.

This entry is part 2 of 10 in the series 2025 Mock Drafts | Dynasty Fantasy Football | NFL Draft

wp-content/uploads/2023/05/NFL-mDraft-1.jpg

2025 Mock Drafts | Dynasty Fantasy Football | NFL Draft

The following 4-round 2025 SF rookie mock draft was compiled by Dynasty Nerds Keith Ensminger, Doc Mitchell, Bobby Bishop, Mike Johrendt, Mike Hicks, and Peter Monahan with the help of Editor-in-Chief Taylor Christianson (@mysleepers). We encourage you to contact us or our editor directly with any questions or suggestions for upcoming mock drafts.

2025 SuperFlex (SF) Rookie Mock Draft

The scoring and format for this SF Rookie Mock Draft are as follows:

4 points per passing touchdown (PPTD)
1 point per reception (PPR)
NO Tight End Premium

This is a 12-team, start 10 (QB, RBx2, WRx3, RB/WR/TEx3, SF) SuperFlex Rookie Mock Draft. Please let us know if there are other formats you would like to see!

The SF Rookie Mock Draft Was Aided By The Dynasty Nerds Film Room!

The video clips used in this SF rookie mock draft were curated and arranged by Dynasty Nerds Film Room Manager Matt Cooper (@CouchScoutsFF). A special thanks to Matt and all the Film Room crew for the awesome quality content they provide for us and our subscribers. Use code MOCK-DRAFT for 15% off your own Film Room Subscription and start scouting rookie prospects in All-22 footage like a Nerd!

Rounds One | Two | Three | Four

ROUND ONE | 2025 SUPERFLEX MOCK DRAFT

No. 1 Selection | SF Rookie Mock | 2025 NFL Draft

1.01 | Ashton Jeanty | RB | Boise State | 5’9” | 215 lbs

Peter Monahan: I finally got the 1.01 selection in one of our mock drafts. As I’m sure you’ve noticed by now, Ashton Jeanty is the clear 1.01 choice in both 1QB and SF Mock Drafts. For this mock in particular, I wanted to find one unique and incredible stat about each prospect. Ashton Jeanty rushed for 2,497 yards this past season (not counting the College Football Playoff game versus Penn State). There are 133 FBS teams and 115 of them did not reach the total that Jeanty did as an entire TEAM.

As mentioned above, there was no alternative player or position as I was considering with the 1.01 selection at this stage in the off-season before the NFL Draft. Given this is a Superflex league, quarterbacks do tend to get pushed up draft boards; however, in my opinion, neither of the top quarterback options in this draft class is worthy of the 1.01 selection. Anytime you have the 1.01 choice you hold the keys to the kingdom. You have the option of selecting any player available, but the value of the 1.01 draft pick as a trade asset cannot be overstated.

No. 2 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

1.02 | Tetairoa McMillan | WR | Arizona | 6’5” | 212 lbs

Mike Hicks: With the 1.02, I am happy taking the no. 1 consensus wide receiver, Tetairoa McMillan from the University of Arizona. He is in a tier of his own. McMillan was the WR1 going into the 2024 season and did nothing to change that throughout. He had 84 receptions, 1,319 yards, and 8 touchdowns in 12 games. McMillan had 26 touchdowns in his 3 seasons in college. Tet McMillan is poised to be a Top 10, maybe even a Top 5 draft pick in April, which cements him as my 1.02 even more in rookie drafts.

McMillan’s size, route running, and overall ball skills make him the elite prospect that he is. However, in a Superflex draft, there were other considerations at 1.02. The value of the quarterback position can’t be ignored in SF drafts. It was personally between McMillan and Cam Ward. I believe McMillan is too good of a talent to pass up, including over any QB in this draft class.

No. 3 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

1.03 | Cam Ward | QB | Miami | 6’2” | 225 lbs

Mike Johrendt: Cam Ward made the jump from Incarnate World to Washington State and finally landed in Miami, so he has pretty much seen it all in the world of college football. While only playing a lone season with the Hurricanes, Ward threw for the most touchdowns (39), the 2nd-most passing yards (4,313) and yards per game (313.8), and the 4th-highest passer rating (172.2), while only throwing 7 interceptions.

With both Jeanty and McMillan off the board, it was between Ward and Shedeur Sanders at 1.03. The selection went in favor of Ward, who offers a higher upside and performed better than Sanders when compared head-to-head last season. The 1.03 pick makes the most sense to start the QB run as both Jeanty and McMillan are better values. With the rookie QB class being a bit weaker than most years, Ward headlines the group, but really isn’t worthy of the top selection. This early on in your rookie drafts, it doesn’t make sense to move down unless you receive a massive offer for this pick.

No. 4 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

1.04 | Shedeur Sanders | QB | Colorado | 6’2” | 215 lbs

Keith Ensminger: Shedeur Sanders, this year’s Johnny Unitas Golden Arm Award winner for the top underclassman quarterback, led the Colorado Buffaloes to a 9 win season in 2024. He threw for 4,134 yards and 37 touchdowns with a 74% completion rate. Additionally, Sanders averaged 8.7 yards per passing attempt which ranked as one of the highest in college football. However, there are negatives, too. Sanders was sacked 42 times—the most in the FBS. Is this a result of a poor offensive line or does he hold onto the ball too long?

In SuperFlex formats, I will always lean toward selecting a highly-drafted quarterback over other positions. However, after Cam Ward, Ashton Jeanty, and Tetairoa McMillan, I see a drop off in value. I would be actively trying to trade down in the 1st round, possibly a trade like 1.04 for 1.07 and 2.07, or perhaps 1.04 for 1.11 and a 1st round pick in the talented 2027 rookie class. I do like Sanders, but I think there is better value to be had later in this round.

No. 5 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

1.05 | TreVeyon Henderson* | RB | Ohio State | 5’10” | 208 lbs

“Doc” Matthew Mitchell: Before I break down the 1.05 pick, I want to notate that I originally selected Quinshon Judkins with this selection.* Upon further reflection, we decided to exclude him from this mock draft since, at the time of the draft, there was some uncertainty as to whether or not he would declare for the NFL draft. That being said, I was extremely happy to get TreVeyon Henderson with this pick. The lightning of the Buckeyes’ two backs, Henderson is a blink away from taking it to the house on any play. He turned his 144 carries into 1,016 rushing yards and 10 TDs. This was his second 1,000 yard season of his collegiate career and he firmly established himself as one of the most electric players in the nation throughout the Buckeyes’ championship run.

Heading into his NFL career, I believe that Henderson has the potential to be a weapon in both the running and passing game. His skill set falls somewhere between Jahmyr Gibbs and Alvin Kamara. I believe he will be best utilized in tandem with a bigger back that will take some of the carries off of his legs. I believe that he will test exceptionally well in the pre-draft process and should hear his name called sometime on Day 2 of the NFL draft. He would be an ideal fit in Chicago under new HC Ben Johnson. However, there a number of favorable destinations he could land owing to his skill set. Henderson might not be a bell cow at the next level, but he will almost certainly get that uber-valuable receiving game work along with a healthy dose of touches between the 20’s. If I am in a PPR league, I put Henderson as my RB3 (behind Jeanty and Judkins) in the class and am more than happy to scoop him up here with the 5th overall pick.

No. 6 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

1.06 | Luther Burden III | WR | Missouri | 5’11” | 208 lbs

Bobby Bishop: Luther Burden III had a down year in 2024, but he is still the same dynamic receiver. His 2023 stats showcase his ability: 86 receptions, 1212 receiving yards, and 9 receiving touchdowns. Burden has some D.J. Moore to his game (although skinnier than Moore). Burden can be a deep threat, but his best skill is racking up yards after the catch.

Luther Burden III is my WR3, but I’m drafting him here as my WR2. Why? Because I know that he is playing receiver full time. If Travis Hunter announces that he will play wide receiver full time at the next level, Hunter will rocket up draft boards. At the moment, Burden III is the safer pick. I love targeting receivers in round 1, because their careers typically last longer than running backs.

No. 7 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

1.07 | Omarion Hampton | RB | North Carolina | 6’0” | 220 lbs

Peter: The way this draft board played out with 2 running backs, 2 wide receivers, and 2 quarterbacks being selected, I was able to land my RB2 in the class Omarion Hampton. As a sophomore two seasons ago, Hampton ran for 1,504 yards—the most by a North Carolina running back in 53 years. For his encore junior season, Hampton topped his own record to rush for 1,660 yards and tacked on another 373 receiving for over 2,000 yards from scrimmage.

This running back class is one of the deepest in talent in recent memory, so many people might tell you to wait and select a similar caliber back later in the draft. However, I believe Hampton is a true workhorse, 3-down running back who an NFL team should easily fall in love with. He might just earn himself that coveted bell-cow role for fantasy. There are several tier-1 and tier-2 running back options that I could have considered here, but I think Hampton stands above the rest. I would be ecstatic to use a mid-1st round pick on him.

No. 8 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

1.08 | Kaleb Johnson | RB | Iowa | 6’0” | 225 lbs

Mike H: Kaleb Johnson has moved up rookie rankings throughout the 2024 season. In 12 games, Johnson ran for 1,536 yards and 21 touchdowns on 240 attempts. In his first 2 seasons, he had 7 total receptions. But in 2024, he had 22 receptions and 2 receiving touchdowns. Johnson has the size and frame combination to be a workhorse running back in the NFL.

Johnson has great vision and overall acceleration that gives him the opportunity to be a Day 2 NFL draft pick. Assuming that’s the case, he is a great pick at 1.08, but it’s not a slam dunk pick. For me, the 1.08 was between Johnson and wide receiver Emeka Egbuka. Getting one of the last running backs in my second tier is why I took Johnson. But my ideal situation here would be to trade down a few picks in the 1st round or the beginning of the 2nd. Either way, if you are at 1.08 and Johnson is available, he is absolutely worth consideration.

No. 9 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

1.09 | Emeka Egbuka | WR | Ohio State | 6’1” | 206 lbs

Mike J: Back on the clock at pick 1.09, my selection here is Ohio State’s Emeka Egbuka, who has flown under the radar a bit. Coming out of the Buckeye wide receiver factory, Egbuka finished out his OSU career with a 1,011-yard season, hauling in a career-best 81 passes for 10 TDs. Egbuka was overshadowed in the headlines by freshman Jeremiah Smith, and that should help him fall a bit in your rookie drafts.

Egbuka makes the most sense at pick 1.09, especially with this not being a tight-end premium (TEP) format. While looking at the TE group here would work, Egbuka is my WR3 and checks a lot of boxes for a player picked in the late 1st. If looking to trade back from here, this is the range where you could do that, especially if you would be acquiring an early 2nd plus more.

No. 10 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

1.10 | Jalen Milroe | QB | Alabama | 6’2” | 220 lbs

Keith: Jalen Milroe is an explosive dual-threat quarterback with the potential to become a standout NFL player and a fantasy football cheat code. The 2024 William V. Campbell Trophy winner, Milroe has been praised as a great teammate and leader. He completed 64.3% of his passes for 2,844 yards, adding 16 touchdowns and 11 interceptions. Milroe excelled on the ground, rushing for 726 yards and 20 touchdowns while showcasing his dynamic playmaking ability.

The buzz around Milroe’s rise in the 2025 NFL Draft is growing louder, with recent mock drafts from prominent analysts placing him as high as 3rd (Chris Trapasso) to the Giants and 9th (Thor Nystrom) to the Saints. If Milroe is taken in the 1st round of the 2025 NFL Draft, we cannot let him drop this far in rookie drafts. Should he become even an average passer, his upside as a rushing quarterback is simply too valuable to pass up. Managers who hesitated to draft Bo Nix and Michael Penix earlier in 2024 likely now regret it, and Milroe could be another case of high-reward potential. Though he carries a wide range of outcomes, he offers a ceiling that exceeds any other player available, even Ashton Jeanty.

No. 11 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

1.11 | Tyler Warren | TE | Penn State | 6’6” | 257 lbs

Doc: This was the easiest pick of the draft for me. I love Tyler Warren and the potential he brings to the table heading into his NFL career. Big and extremely dynamic with the ball in his hands, Warren set not only PSU records this season, but also set Big 10 benchmarks across the board with his massive 104-catch workload for 1,233 yards and 8 TDs. As if this wasn’t impressive enough, Warren also turned 26 carries into 218 yards and 4 TDs. (He threw a TD pass as well.) Simply put, Warren is as dynamic a playmaker as you will find for the TE position—which is why he won the Mackey Award as the nation’s top TE.

Warren is a playmaker on par with Trey McBride and Brock Bowers. He is a near guarantee to be taken in the 1st Round of the upcoming NFL draft. This is the type of TE you want in fantasy football. I will be looking to take him in the back end of the 1st of rookie drafts this coming spring. The 2025 class is shaping up to be one of the best for TEs in some time. There are a number of really good prospects, and this is the top of the heap. As our founder Rich Dotson says, you can never have too many good tight ends on your roster.

No. 12 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

1.12 | Travis Hunter | CB | WR | Colorado | 6’1” | 185 lbs

Bobby: Travis Hunter is one of the most naturally gifted athletes I’ve ever witnessed. His athleticism is effortless, gliding past defenders. He finished the season with 96 receptions, 1,258 yards, and 15 touchdowns. Hunter improved as a route runner, and he has shown an increased versatility to play both slot and outside receiver. He truly may be the best receiver in the class.

He’s also the best cornerback in the class. His intentions are to play both ways in the NFL, but what if his franchise takes the decision out of his hands? What if an injury forces him to play full time one way or the other? Drafting Travis Hunter in dynasty is certainly not a risk-averse move, but here in the late 1st round, I’m thrilled to add a player of his caliber.

Rounds One | Two | Three | Four

ROUND TWO | 2025 NFL DRAFT CLASS

No. 13 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

2.01 | Tre Harris | WR | Ole Miss | 6’3” | 210 lbs

Peter: While I personally believe this wide receiver class is a little bit lacking in true superstar options (outside of Tetairoa McMillan), several guys are going to be solid NFL contributors as WR2-type options. That’s where I view Tre Harris. Harris is my WR5 in this class, and if I was picking from the 1.01 spot in my rookie draft, pairing up Ashton Jeanty with Harris would be a dream come true. Harris is one of only two players in SEC history to average 100 yards receiving per game across his career joining Florida’s Jabar Gaffney.

Harris was the last of my top 5 wide receiver options in this class that I really want to draft, so I would potentially trade up to select him at any pick from here on. There are still a few WRs that I would choose if I needed to fill out my depth to have some options on my bench. However, Harris is someone I can see slotting into my fantasy lineup as a flex option assuming he receives his projected Day 2 draft capital and lands in an offense that would allow him to produce right away.

No. 14 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

2.02 | Jaxson Dart | QB | Ole Miss | 6’2” | 226 lbs

Mike H: Every draft season there is a quarterback or two that move up draft boards through the process. This year, Jaxson Dart should be one of them. Dart has been the starter at Ole Miss since transferring there before the 2022 season. In his senior year, Dart passed for 4,279 yards and 29 touchdowns. There are a few examples of quarterbacks not declaring for the NFL draft after their junior season and it benefitting their draft stock, including Michael Penix Jr. and Bo Nix. Dart could be that guy in 2025.

Jaxson Dart may not be considered a dual-threat quarterback, but he has the ability to get out of the pocket and run with the football when necessary. Accuracy and standing strong in the pocket are two necessities for an NFL quarterback, and Dart has both. He may not be my favorite prospect of the class, but with the value that quarterbacks have in SuperFlex formats, it’s hard to pass up Dart at this point of the draft. If this mock was TEP, I would have possibly gone Colston Loveland.

No. 15 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

2.03 | Devin Neal | RB | Kansas | 5’11” | 220 lbs

Mike J: It was quite the strong collegiate career for Devin Neal, as he racked up 1,000+ rushing yards in each of his final 3 seasons. Neal became more utilized in the passing game as well, hauling in over 20 passes in 3 of 4 seasons. Not the biggest back by any means, Neal was a load to bring down with the Kansas Jayhawks as he was one of their better offensive playmakers these past few seasons.

Neal has been steadily jumping up draft boards as more people dive into his tape. Built like an NFL scat back but a bit heavier, Neal has what it takes to make an impact right out of the gate. There are quite a few targets you could justify in this spot. There is still plenty of depth for TE and WR options.

No. 16 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

2.04 | Colston Loveland | TE | Michigan | 6’5” | 245 lbs

Keith: Highlighted by performances such as his career-high 112 receiving yards against Oregon, Michigan’s Colston Loveland led the anemic Wolverine’s offense in receptions (56), receiving yards (582) and touchdown receptions (5) in 2024. His consistency was often the only thing keeping the Michigan offense afloat, and those efforts earned him second-team All-Big 10 honors and a second-team All-American selection.

Looking at the players available when I made this pick in our 2025 SuperFlex Rookie Mock Draft, Loveland would have been my selection 10 out of 10 times. The only realistic trading pivot I would have considered from this spot would have been to trade up for Jaxson Dart. Naturally, my interest in doing so would depend greatly on his landing spot and how highly he ends up being drafted in the 2025 NFL Draft. That said, I am perfectly happy staying put and taking Loveland. He is among the best prospects in a class full of great tight ends.

No. 17 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

2.05 | Quinn Ewers | QB | Texas | 6’2” | 210 lbs

Doc: Quinn Ewers was once touted as an all-time great High School prospect. However, Quinn had an up-and-down collegiate career at Texas. At least that is the story most will tell you. In actuality, he managed to lead his team twice to the college football semi-final while also picking up a Big 12 Conference Title along the way. Despite his awkward arm delivery, he managed to put up really good numbers in college—twice throwing for over 3,000 yards. He had a career-best 31 TDs this past year in an injury-shortened season.

Ewers offers some nice upside in a Superflex format. I believe Ewers will be drafted within the first 3 rounds of the upcoming draft. The question at this point is just how high will he go? He must have gotten good feedback from scouts and draft analysts as there was a recent report that he turned down an 8-million-dollar NIL offer from a major college to play one more season of college football. Ewers will need to be selected in the top 50 players to make the same amount or more. He would be an ideal 2nd round selection for a team that misses out on the top two QBs in this thin class. He could also go in the back half of the 1st to a team like Pittsburgh. If Ewers gets top 50 draft capital, I would be more than happy to snag him here in the 2nd round.

No. 18 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

2.06 | Cam Skattebo | RB | Arizona State | 5’11” | 215 lbs

Bobby: Cam Skattebo was one of the highest rising prospects of any position during the 2024 season. He put up monster numbers: 1711 yards rushing, 21 rushing touchdowns, 605 receiving yards, and 3 receiving touchdowns. The whole Arizona State offense ran through him. Cam Skattebo forced 102 missed tackles, second in the nation to only Ashton Jeanty.

Cam Skattebo has three-down potential, which is rare for modern running backs. If he can win a workhorse role on his team, his fantasy upside is limitless. In this running back class, I view Skattebo as the end of a tier of potential bell-cow backs. I think he is the safest player remaining, but also has the most upside of anyone left. I’m thrilled to add Cam Skattebo to my fantasy teams in the mid 2nd.

No. 19 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

2.07 | Dylan Sampson | RB | Tennessee | 5’11” | 201 lbs

Peter: Dylan Sampson may just end up being the underrated running back in this class, and I can see some comparisons to Bucky Irving in terms of his potential breakout ability at the next level. In the incredibly tough SEC conference, Sampson set the Tennessee single-season school record for both touchdowns (22) and rushing yards (1,491) while also tying for 5th in SEC history on the single-season touchdown list behind the likes of Derrick Henry, Najee Harris, Tre Mason, and Tim Tebow (he tied with Leonard Fournette).

Sampson is the perfect example of how deep this running back class is. If I have a late 1st round pick or early 2nd round pick, that is exactly the range that I would be trading back for multiple selections in the mid- to late-2nd round in this years stacked running back class. In this class, we aren’t sure which running backs are truly going to have the opportunity to succeed in what are sure to become some crowded NFL depth charts. I prefer to take as many chances as I can get this year to hopefully hit on the Bucky Irving and Tyrone Tracy’s of this class.

No. 20 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

2.08 | Isaiah Bond | WR | Texas | 5’11” | 180 lbs

Mike H: There are some skills that NFL teams like more than others, and speed might be at the top of that list. Isaiah Bond is towards the top of the list of speedsters at the wide receiver position coming into the 2025 draft class. Bond had 34 receptions, 540 yards, and 5 touchdowns in 14 games. Unfortunately, he had a disappointing 2024 season, which is one reason he isn’t higher than the 2.08 in this mock draft. But I expect him to rebound some of his value throughout the draft process.

Yes, Bond has elite speed, but he is not a one-trick pony as a wide receiver prospect. He is an above-average route runner and is good at gaining separation against opposing defensive backs. It is also likely that he is used in special teams at the beginning of his NFL career. In this part of the draft, there are many wide receivers to consider besides Bond. For that reason, I would also consider trading out of 2.08 and getting multiple picks toward the back end of the 2nd or beginning of 3rd round.

No. 21 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

2.09 | Xavier Restrepo | WR | Miami | 5’10” | 200 lbs

Mike J: It was quite the senior season for Xavier Restrepo—the second Hurricane I’ve selected in our mock draft. Setting a single-season program mark for receptions (85), Restrepo was one of Cam Ward’s most trusted targets this past season. Restrepo recorded two consecutive 1,000-yard campaigns with Miami. His senior season (1,127) being his most. He also found the end zone 11 times this past season, sending himself into the NFL on a high note.

The downside to Restrepo is that his body size pretty much relegates him to a slot role at the next level. While we have seen other options (Ladd McConkey most recently) escape the slot moniker, Restrepo will need to show a lot to do that. He is by no means a locked-in option at this spot as you could look to another player in this range, but Restrepo should absolutely be in discussion near the end of the second round.

No. 22 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

2.10 | DJ Giddens | RB | Kansas State | 6’1” | 212 lbs

Keith: A player being slept on in this draft class is Kansas State running back DJ Giddens. Giddens was one of the premier backs in college football in the 2024 season. Although he sat out their post-season bowl game, Giddins started all 12 regular-season games, rushing for 1,343 yards on 205 carries and scoring 7 touchdowns. He also contributed 21 receptions for 258 yards through the air. Giddens earned a spot on the All-Big 12 Second Team in a conference loaded with tough competition at his position.

I believe our team did an excellent job in this 2025 SuperFlex Rookie Mock draft, so it would be hard for me to single out any one player still available I would rather have than Giddens. A likely early selection on Day 3 of the 2025 NFL Draft, this is the perfect spot for Giddens in rookie drafts. Good dynasty roster construction dictates drafting rookie running backs who gain value when given a clear starting opportunity over filling your team with roster-clogging wide receivers who can never be trusted in lineups.

No. 23 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

2.11 | Harold Fannin Jr. | TE | Bowling Green | 6’4” | 230 lbs

Doc: Here in the back half of the 2nd round, I am going back to the well at the TE position. Harold Fannin Jr. is an enigma in this year’s draft. He is by far the most prolific at the position. He reeled in an absurd 117 catches and turned them into an eye-popping 1,555 yards and 10 TDs! You would normally be fair in questioning if he just beat up on small schools, but that wasn’t the case. Fannin played 2 games against ranked teams and turned them into 11 receptions for 137 yards and 1 TD against No. 8 Penn State and 8 for 145 and 1 against No. 25 Texas A&M.

Fannin is a joker type of player. His future NFL and fantasy value will depend heavily on where he lands in the upcoming NFL draft. Fannin is a bit on the small side for an NFL TE. He would benefit greatly from landing with a creative offensive coach who is capable of finding ways to use him as something of a hybrid big slot WR and TE combined. If he manages to find his way to the right spot, Fannin could be a cheat code at the TE position. Think Evan Engram with hands. Give me that type of upside late in the 2nd round of rookie drafts all day, every day.

No. 24 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

2.12 | Will Howard | QB | Ohio State | 6’4” | 235 lbs

Bobby: Will Howard is coming off a National Championship and by far the best season of his career. Howard put up 4,010 yards passing and threw for 35 touchdowns this season. His ceiling may not be as high as others in this class, but he’s a solid Day 2 Quarterback. He can operate an offense, get the ball out quick, and he has good deep ball accuracy. He’s also sneaky athletic, adding 16 rushing touchdowns the last 2 seasons.

After getting sniped on Harold Fannin Jr., I felt like the upside of a potential starting quarterback was too good to pass up in a superflex league. Even though he is my QB6, I believe Howard has a higher floor than Quinn Ewers, Jalen Milroe, and Jaxson Dart. I considered adding a wide receiver here, but I have confidence that Will Howard will eventually get an opportunity to start at the NFL level.

Rounds One | Two | Three | Four

ROUND THREE | 2025 NFL DRAFT CLASS

No. 25 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

3.01 | RJ Harvey | RB | UCF | 5’8′ | 207 lbs

Peter: University of Central Florida senior running back RJ Harvey is the school’s all-time leader in total touchdowns, 1 of 4 running backs with 4,000 all-purpose yards, and 1 of 3 to average over 100 yards from scrimmage. Perhaps the most surprising stat for Harvey is that he is the 5th leading rusher in this draft class. Harvey may get knocked for being a little undersized and for playing at a smaller school against lesser competition, but make no mistake—he has the tools and skillset to compete and succeed at the next level.

Now that we have reached the third round of the draft, my strategy is just to select any and all running backs or quarterbacks as those are the two positions that have the clearest path to playing time due to injury. Harvey is another underrated name in this class that I feel will be a great complement back with some receiving ability as well. Getting a guy like Harvey here in the third round almost doesn’t seem fair.

No. 26 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

3.02 | Jordan James | RB | Oregon | 5’10” | 210 lbs

Mike H: In a draft class that is deep at the running back position, I will take a player at 3.02 that I consider top 10 at the position all day, every day. As the backup during his sophomore season, Jordan James had 759 rushing yards, 11 touchdowns, and 15 receptions. James broke out as a junior with 1,267 yards, 15 touchdowns, and 26 receptions.

James’ patience, vision, and great acceleration allow him to succeed at the line of scrimmage. He has the ability to become an every down back and be involved in the passing game. I couldn’t pass up taking a top 10 running back at this point in the draft. However, there are options, mainly at wide receiver—players like Elic Ayomanor, Jalen Royals, and Matthew Golden. I am taking James over the wide receivers because of his overall talent and positional value.

No. 27 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

3.03 | Elic Ayomanor | WR | Stanford | 6’2” | 210 lbs

Mike J: Elic Ayomanor has been a hot name in dynasty draft prep this offseason as his speed and two-year production at Stanford really jump out. Finding the end zone six times each year, Ayomanor used his tall frame and athleticism to be one of the more trusted targets on the maligned Stanford offense.

The concerns with Ayomanor coming out of school are his separation skills, which show up inconsistently on tape. Good hands and a physical catch point help Ayomanor stand out among other pass catchers in this rookie class. He has positive aspects to get excited over. The receiver class is a deep one in terms of quantity this year, and the NFL landing spot makes a huge difference for how early you should draft Ayomanor.

No. 28 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

3.04 | Kalel Mullings | RB | Michigan | 6’2” | 233 lbs

Keith: If Colston Loveland was the elegant brushstroke in Michigan’s offense, then Kalel Mullings was its chisel; hammering and chipping away at opposing defenses. A former linebacker, Mullings emerged as a key contributor this season, leading the team with 948 rushing yards and 12 touchdowns. Mullings showcased his versatility and power in performances such as his 159-yard, 2-touchdown effort against USC. Most notably, Mullings went off for 116 yards and a touchdown in Michigan’s incredible victory over Ohio State.

Now that our 2025 SuperFlex Rookie Mock Draft is in the third round, it is time for the proverbial “get your guys” part of this exercise. I am all about taking running backs and tight ends this late, although I was hoping Jayden Higgins would fall to my pick at 3.10. Outside of Higgins, though, the only players I want from this point on are players who I believe have a chance to gain value in the right situation. I am drafting for ceiling and value rather than trying to fill openings in my lineup. Mullings may never be a superstar in the NFL, but if he can become Brian Robinson Jr. or Jordan Howard, I’ll take it.

No. 29 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

3.05 | Jalen Royals | WR | Utah State | 6’0” | 210 lbs

Doc: This one might be a bit of a risk, but I am gambling on upside here in the 3rd round. Royals has been one of the top WRs in the Mountain West for the last two seasons. He only managed to play 7 games this season due to a foot injury, but in those games he left a big impression. Across those games, Royals managed to catch 55 passes for 834 yards and 6 scores. In the Aggies game against a really good Boise State team, Royals turned 9 catches into 211 yards and 2 TDs!

Royals will need to prove that he is over his foot injury in the pre-draft process as he looks to impress some NFL scouts. He is lucky to be in a wide-open WR class with very little consensus past the top 4 or 5 players. When I watch Royals play, I see a poor man’s D.J. Moore. He has really nice YAC ability, moving almost like an RB once he gets the ball in his hands. This is the type of player who can operate downfield or get a screen and allow make his way behind blockers. It is a gamble taking Royals here in the 3rd, but the juice is worth the squeeze.

No. 30 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

3.06 | Jayden Higgins | WR | Iowa State | 6’4” | 217 lbs

Bobby: Jayden Higgins is a massive receiver who is surprising agile for his weight. It’s rare that you find bigger receivers that create this much separation. Higgins is also adept at snagging jump balls. Jayden Higgins finished 2024 with 87 receptions, 1183 receiving yards, and 9 receiving touchdowns. At the Senior Bowl, Jayden Higgins has a great opportunity to rise up draft boards.

I was between Higgins and Matthew Golden with this selection. I think Golden will be a good receiver in the NFL, but I think Higgins has more upside. I’m trying to load up on 3rd round picks in my leagues, because I love several of the receivers in this range. Jayden Higgins is definitely one of “my guys.”

No. 31 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

3.07 | Jaydon Blue | RB | Texas | 6’0” | 200 lbs

Peter: Jaydon Blue is a unique prospect in this draft class as he does not have a ton of production or starting experience under his belt. Blue started only 5 out of 37 career games in college, but did average 83.3 yards rushing in games where he had double-digit carries. I was a little surprised that Blue elected to declare for the NFL Draft given he was overtaken this year on his own team. However, Blue did show some great receiving skills with over 40 receptions this season.

We are now at the point of the draft where the hit rates are less than a 10% chance that any of these selections will become relevant to your fantasy team. However, the type of player that you should be selecting in this range is someone with a specific role, and I can see Blue potentially being a 3rd down receiving back option. I will also note that from this pick and on, I do not mind re-rolling and trading for a future 3rd round selection to keep flexibility as you hope for potentially a higher draft pick next season.

No. 32 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

3.08 | Matthew Golden | WR | Texas | 6’0” | 195 lbs

Mike H: This is the time in drafts where I like to take a chance on a “my guy” if the chance presents itself. Matthew Golden has moved up the ranks as of late, and some believe he is the better University of Texas wide receiver. In 2024, after transferring from Houston, Golden had 58 receptions, 987 yards, and 9 touchdowns. Taking an upside player at this point of a rookie draft is a no brainer.

Golden has some weaknesses like all players, but he has skills that make him a good pick in the middle to late parts of the 3rd round. He has good route running and play-making abilities. His hands and ball skills are also a plus. I was debating between Golden and running back Woody Marks here at 3.08. At this point, I had to go with my gut and take the player who should have the higher ceiling.

No. 33 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

3.09 | Woody (Jo’quavious) Marks | RB | USC | 5’10” | 215 lbs

Mike J: Woody Marks found his way with Mississippi State and USC in the passing game, hauling in 261 passes in his 5-year career. Marks also earned 100+ carries in each of his last 4 seasons, including a career-best in his lone season with the Trojans.

Marks enters the NFL with the prototypical build of a receiving back and will likely be drafted into a scheme that sets him up in that role. He will be an ideal third-round selection in PPR formats as he profiles to see most of his work catching passes out of the backfield. Don’t expect Marks to earn an RB1 role out of the gate—if ever—but he absolutely can be a consistent threat in the passing game.

No. 34 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

3.10 | Bhayshul Tuten | RB | Virginia Tech | 5’9” | 211 lbs

Keith: Another player who will begin to gain buzz over the next few months leading up to the 2025 NFL Draft is Virginia Tech’s Bhayshul Tuten. In 2024, he gained 1,159 rushing yards on just 183 carries, scoring 15 touchdowns. Watch his record-breaking game against Boston College where he ran for a school-record 266 yards and 3 touchdowns to see his ceiling. A member of the All-ACC Second Team, Tuten’s consistent excellence in Blacksburg, VA with the Hokies landed him an invite to the Senior Bowl.

As with my previous blurbs, I am looking mostly for running backs and tight ends in this part of the draft. Tuten in particular is a player I will try to quietly target in this part of 2025 SuperFlex rookie drafts. He is currently ranked 22nd on my January 2025 Rookie Big Board, so to get him here at the end of the third round is exciting. Will he continue to be available this late by the time March and April come around? Time will tell.

No. 35 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

3.11 | Tahj Brooks | RB | Texas Tech | 5’10” | 230 lbs

Doc: The 2025 draft is about the running backs, so with that in mind, I went back to the well here at the end of the 3rd taking Texas Tech’s Tahj Brooks. He is an absolute bowling ball of a man. At just 5’10”, he brings the load at 230 lbs. I always find it interesting when bigger RBs look to avoid using their size to their advantage. Brooks is not one of those types of players as he has quietly put up consecutive seasons of over 1,500 rushing yards and double digit TDs. Equally impressive is the fact that he has also 3-straight years of over 25 catches. He doesn’t have an overdrive speed gear, but past that, he has much of what you look for in a 3-down RB.

Now don’t get me wrong, I don’t think that Brooks will be a three-down RB in the NFL. But, he’s got that skill set. I believe that he will find himself drafted early on Day 3 of the NFL draft. If he lands in the right spot, Brooks could be an excellent tandem back bringing the hammer (not unlike Zack Moss) over the course of his career. For fantasy purposes, he could be a flex play with the potential for more depending upon the depth chart he lands with and how high he is drafted.

No. 36 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

3.12 | Savion Williams | WR | TCU | 6’5” | 225 lbs

Bobby: Some dynasty managers will turn and run when faced with a TCU wide receiver. Always scout the player, not the helmet. Savion Williams is a very interesting prospect. He’s more of a weapon than a wide receiver. TCU tried to get the ball in his hands as often as possible: passes behind the line of scrimmage, hand offs, and even direct snaps. Williams is dynamic after the catch, almost like a 6’5” Deebo Samuel.

Draft capital will be extremely telling for Savion Williams’ future. If he is a Day 2 pick, a team may be willing to manufacture touches for him.It’s rare to see teams put effort into getting a Day 3 pick involved in their offense. Savion Williams definitely has areas to improve as a pure wide receiver; however, he clearly has an above average NFL body and athleticism. He’s going to be a project at the next level, but one I’m willing to invest in at this price point.

Rounds One | Two | Three | Four

ROUND FOUR | 2025 NFL DRAFT CLASS

No. 37 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

4.01 | LeQuint Allen | RB | Syracuse | 6’0” | 207 lbs

Peter: I know I probably sound like a broken record at this point, but the amount of quality running backs in this 2025 class is remarkable. LeQuint Allen is no exception and is a high-end receiving option who led all FBS running backs with 64 receptions (the most since the 2021 season). Allen was1 of only 2 players this season (Cam Skattebo) to have over 1,000 yards rushing and over 500 yards receiving. He set the Syracuse single-season record for receptions (64) and receiving yards (521) by a running back.

I almost selected Allen with my last pick at 3.07 until I realized Jaydon Blue had declared (who I think has higher name recognition from his College Football Playoff run and national presence at Texas). This means I have a 3rd round grade on Allen, so selecting him in the 4th round is great value. Similar to my previous selection of Blue, Allen has that coveted receiving ability but can also be an early down grinder as well. You are usually just throwing darts in the 4th round of rookie drafts anyway, but you might just hit a bullseye if you select Allen.

No. 38 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

4.02 | Trevor Etienne | RB | Georgia | 5’9” | 205 lbs

Mike H: In the 4th round of rookie drafts, it’s about taking chances on players that could impact your fantasy rosters. Trevor Etienne is a prime prospect that could move up the ranks through the draft process, especially with a good Combine and pro day performance. His value has dropped some since transferring from the University of Florida. In 2024, he had 609 rushing yards, 9 touchdowns, and 32 receptions.

SuperFlex SF Rookie Mock Draft 2025 NFL Prospects to know best college players dynasty fantasy football ff quarterback running back wide receiver tight end QB RB WR TE Ultimate top 50 new updated release — (Photo by David Rosenblum/Icon Sportswire)

Etienne is not a fully polished prospect, but who is in the 4th round of drafts? He is a North and South runner who is physical and has the ability to finish strong runs. He has the skills to be good in the screen game but needs to work on his route running in the general passing game. Things can change before the draft, but Etienne is the perfect type of RB to take a chance on this late in drafts.

No. 39 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

4.03 | Tez Johnson | WR | Oregon | 5’9” | 156 lbs

Mike J: Tez Johnson is going to be knocked for his size as he enters the NFL Draft, but his tape paints an entirely different story. Johnson can fly and he is the type of game-changer from the slot that can help elevate an NFL offense to the next level. Having transferred to Oregon for the final 2 years of college, Johnson racked up consecutive 83+ reception seasons—scoring 10 TDs in each.

Tank Dell is absolutely the NFL comp for Johnson, who has a similar body comp and play style as the Houston Texans wideout. With that comparison comes an unfortunate expectation of injuries for Johnson, as his slim stature might not allow for him to withstand heavy hits. But his strong route running abilities will elevate him in the NFL Draft, and he feels like a fantastic find here in the 4th round.

No. 40 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

4.04 | Gunnar Helm | TE | Texas | 6’5” | 239 lbs

Keith: Did I mention this class is full of potentially great tight end prospects? Look no further than this man, Texas’ Gunnar Helm. Over 16 games, including the College Football Playoff, Helm recorded 60 receptions for 786 yards and scored 7 touchdowns. He was a semifinalist for the John Mackey Award, recognizing the nation’s top tight end.

Helm is my TE3 in this class behind only Tyler Warren and Colston Loveland. Getting Helm in the 4th round of this 2025 SuperFlex Rookie Mock Draft could be a steal. He compares well to a player like Hunter Henry. Helm may never be the NFL’s top tight end, but given the right offense, he could find himself as a tight end dynasty managers are willing to put into their lineup. They could do far worse.

No. 41 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

4.05 | Tai Felton | WR | Maryland | 6’1” | 186 lbs

Doc: In the final round of this mock draft I am looking for upside. With the first of my 4th-round picks, I took Maryland’s record-setting WR Tai Felton. This smooth 6’2” WR broke D.J. Moore’s school record for catches in a season, bringing in 96 catches for 1,124 yards and 9 TDs. Felton has shown an ability to win against all levels of a defense. He lacks that real top-end speed but has the height and length to make up for it with size and technique.

I have enjoyed watching Felton play this season. He caught my attention early on with his blistering 4-game stretch to open the year. Felton will have the perfect opportunity to catch the eye of an NFL team at the upcoming Senior Bowl. I believe that in this class, he will go somewhere from the end of Day 2 to the beginning of Day 3 of the upcoming NFL draft. The faster he runs in testing, the earlier he will go. I’m happy to scoop him up here in the 4th.

No. 42 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

4.06 | Dillon Gabriel | QB | Oregon | 5’11” | 202 lbs

Bobby: If you want to find a QB prospect with more experience than Dillon Gabriel, good luck. Gabriel has been a starter for 6 seasons (2021 got cut short due to a broken left clavicle) across 3 programs. He’s accumulated 18,722 passing yards and 155 passing touchdowns. Gabriel is surprisingly mobile with 33 rushing touchdowns in his college career. He has shown an ability to operate three different offenses.

As a 4th round pick in the 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft, I’m excited to make this investment in Dillon Gabriel. He’ll likely be a 3rd or 4th Round pick come April and will start off as a backup for his NFL team. Gabriel will be one injury away from having a starting opportunity and a sell window. In superflex leagues, I love drafting QBs late in rookie drafts. The hit rate may be low, but the value is tremendous when they hit. I considered several running backs with this pick, but the upside of a quarterback is far beyond that of a committee running back. I’m excited to add Dillon Gabriel to my fantasy teams this late in the draft.

No. 43 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

4.07 | Raheim Sanders | RB | South Carolina | 6’0” | 230 lbs

Peter: Raheim (Rocket) Sanders is a former devy darling who at one point was the RB1 in the 2024 class and on track for future NFL stardom. Following his sophomore season in 2022 and heading into his junior year in 2023, Sanders was the only player in the nation with 1,400 yards rushing and 250 yards receiving in his career. In a game versus Missouri State during the 2022 season, Sanders became 1 of just 2 SEC players (Florida’s Percy Harvin) since 2000 to record 150+ rushing yards with a rushing TD and 70+ receiving yards with a receiving TD.

If you play in any devy fantasy leagues (devy leagues are where you can select players still in college and they are added to your fantasy roster once they reach the NFL) you know the name Raheim Sanders. I was super high on Sanders, but the injuries in his junior season derailed what might have been. Thankfully, he had somewhat of a bounce-back senior season in Columbia which put him back on the NFL radar. You can certainly do worse with your 4th round pick, and I think the pick of Sanders rounded out my draft selections nicely.

No. 44 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

4.08 | Kyle Monangai | RB | Rutgers | 5’9” | 209 lbs

Mike H: Rookie drafts are all about chance, especially in the middle of the 4th round. At this point, there are hits, misses, and taxi squad gambles. Running back Kyle Monangai has the chance to have a role in an NFL offense. He had 1,279 and 13 touchdowns on a weak Rutgers offense. Who knows what he could have done on a more potent offense.

Monangai has good vision and is good at setting up blocks at the line of scrimmage. He is also solid in pass protection which could be one of his biggest calling cards to an NFL career. His success will depend a lot on his landing spot. Nothing is a guarantee this late in drafts, but Monangai is a player I will be taking a chance on in rookie drafts and will have a decent percentage of Monangai in my portfolio.

No. 45 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

4.09 | Ollie Gordon II | RB | Oklahoma State | 6’1” | 233 lbs

Mike J: My final selection in this mock draft is Ollie Gordon II, running back from Oklahoma State. As an early declare, Gordon enters the NFL Draft one year removed from winning the Doak Walker Award in a year he rushed for 1,732 yards and 21 TDs. While his junior season was less impressive (880 rushing yards), Gordon still found the end zone 13 times.

Gordon falls behind a slew of other RBs due to his burst and failing to capitalize on his big sophomore season. But his workload and dual-threat abilities set himself up to potentially fill a lead-back role at the next level. In the fourth round, Gordon is absolutely the dart throw you want to take.

No. 46 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

4.10 | Damien Martinez | RB | Miami | 5’11” | 226 lbs

Keith: The 2024 College Football season was supposed to be Damien Martinez’ time to shine. The transfer from Oregon State came to Miami intending to be the focal point of the Hurricane’s offense. Fate and Cam Ward intervened in that plan. The one-time All-Pac 12 Freshman of the Year and All-Pac 12 First Team member was able to showcase his skills despite playing in the shadow of Ward, rushing for 1,002 yards and 9 touchdowns.

It is possible that Martinez’s best football still lies ahead, and at the very end of our 2025 SuperFlex Rookie Mock draft, that is precisely the type of ceiling I am looking for in these late-round draft picks. He is a physical runner but has the potential to be a three-down back if he develops further as a pass-catcher. Martinez has a bit of James Conner to his game, and I believe he will find his way onto both an NFL final roster and my dynasty team’s taxi squad.

No. 47 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

4.11 | Oronde Gadsden II | TE | Syracuse | 6’5” | 236 lbs

Doc: With my last pick of this mock draft I was swinging for the fences. We’ve been saying that 2025 is the year of the TE. I grabbed one in the 1st and 2nd round, and I am going to finish up with one here at the end. Oronde Gadsden is a unique type of player. Somewhat like Harold Fannin Jr. who we mentioned before, Gadsden is a bit of a tweener. He is big for a WR, but small (and a bit of a liability) as a blocker for being a TE. Despite these deficiencies, Syracuse saw his value and got multiple years of over 900 receiving yards from him, including 2024 where he caught 73 passes for 934 yards and 7 scores.

(Photo by Gregory Fisher/Icon Sportswire)

Gadsden comes from an excellent bloodline with his father enjoying a decade-long career in the NFL. Gadsden Jr. is a dynamic player with the ball in his hands. More of a straight-line runner than a twitchy athlete, Gadsden reminds me a little bit of former Raiders TE Darren Waller. We will get a really good look at Gadsden during the practices and game of the upcoming East-West Shrine Bowl. Keep an eye out for tweets of his practice reps—he’s a highlight waiting to happen and an excellent 4th round pick.

No. 48 Selection | 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft

4.12 | Brashard Smith | RB | SMU | 5’9” | 195 lbs

Bobby: If you are looking for this year’s Tyrone Tracy, look no further than Brashard Smith. Both college receivers until switching to running back, Tracy and Smith have a lot in common. Smith is elusive and explosive—a big play waiting to happen. With a strong Senior Bowl performance, Smith could skyrocket up boards.

At minimum, I see Smith as the receiving back in a committee. This draft class is filled with power backs, but there are fewer receiving backs. In a PPR league, a running back who gets 5 or more targets a game is going to produce fantasy points. I am confident that Smith’s skills will earn him a role and targets on an NFL team. I’m thrilled to draft Brashard Smith to close out this 2025 SF Rookie Mock Draft.